Is the hate justified? Lets talk about Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress.

Enter Biba. The sudden main antagonist of the series with a bad case of daddy issues

Let me start by answering a few questions. Did I enjoy watching Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress? Yes. Would I recommend it to others? Yes. Is it a great anime? Not by a long shot…

For the most part, Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress is widely met with disdain in the Anime community. Many reviewers scoring it extremely low, and some go as far as saying it is complete trash. Kabaneri had all the potential to do great things, but fell mountains short of reaching it for a plethora of varied reasons. Before I get into that, I’d like to address the extremely vocal elephant in the room. No, I don’t think Kabaneri is an Attack on Titan clone, poorly executed or otherwise, I just don’t agree. That being said, it is impossible to ignore the glaringly obvious use of many AoT elements within this series.

Kabaneri and Attack on Titan share the same Director, Tetsurō Araki. They also share the same musical composer, Hiroyuki Sawano. Oh and also the same animation team, WIT Studio… Under normal circumstances this wouldn’t even be a thing to bring up. Unfortunately for Kabaneri, Many Attack on Titan fans blame the series production for the multitude of delays the second season of AoT suffered as a probable result. Due to the teams being overworked and under tight schedules.

In my personal opinion, I dont see all of the similarities as a bad thing. The music is beautifully composed and correctly conveys all the right emotion you would expect from the scene. I really enjoyed everything the music had to offer, including the opening song. There was one instance I couldnt ignore though. In episode 7 Ikoma is trying to rally the people, he says something along the lines of “Are you fine living like this?” and I couldn’t help but think Eren Yeager… *eye roll*


It started well…

At first, up until about episode 8, the pacing and direction of the series is very good. We are treated to action packed and beautifully animated scenes where the story seems to be going in a direction that fits the theme of being a survival action horror.

Except that this whole premise gets flipped on its fucking head.

Enter Biba. The sudden main antagonist of the series with a bad case of daddy issues, which has now gone from being a Zombie like survival to a typical revenge plot. WHY!? This made no sense to me. It is ridiculous in this setting. This late into the series with barely 3 episodes left, you want to tell me that the whole thing has been about revenge? Piss off!

Kabaneri_scrn6
~ is it too late now to say sorry? I’m missing more than just your body ~

Characters? Where!?

Regardless of Biba fever and the shitty ending, the biggest problem with Kabaneri is its character development. The series is PLAGUED with uninteresting characters and the lack of fleshed out stories make it hard to buy in to almost anything.

Ikoma starts out to be a seemingly intelligent and talented inventor, but the last thing you see him do that fits this description is in the first episode! He successfully completes his jet gun that can pierce the cages of kabane hearts, and manages to survive the kabane virus after being bitten, by bolting all kinds of shit to his body. Which leads me onto another point.

Not only is it not explained how Kabane came to be, but it is also never explained how Kabaneri are created. Seemingly it is a complex scientific procedure. I find it extremely difficult to believe that Ikoma could do it through sheer will power, giant Lego pieces and choking himself the fuck out!

Kabaneri_scrn4

By episode 11 Ikoma has become a whiny, scared little bitch and I couldn’t bring myself to sympathise with him at all. I haven’t been brought to care for him like I should.

What about the other characters you ask? Lady Ayame is the daughter of some lord making her the leader of some people, thats’ all I know. Kurusu is her samurai bodyguard, that’s all I know. Takumi is Ikomas best friend, that’s all I know. There is so little development here that when one of the cast died in episode 10, I barely noticed. Judging by the character reactions on screen i should have been mortified…

There is a multitude of other characters who appear often in the series and its the same for them all. Hell, even Engrish-San is more interesting than half of the cast and he does NOTHING! The characters are incredibly forgettable and seem to serve almost no purpose to the entire show.

Kabaneri_scrn3
Seriously, can anyone even remember what the hell this persons name was!?

Final note.

If you’ve managed to read this far, then you’re probably thinking i hated this series. I didn’t hate it, like I said at the beginning I actually enjoyed a lot of it. The animation quality was ace and for a animation buff like me, this is important. I constantly found myself impressed by the wonderfully drawn action and the fluidity of the Sakuga sequences. The music always kept me hyped up and I thought the overall design aesthetics of the show were brilliant. For those reasons alone, I would recommend it to others with similar tastes. Kabaneri just severely let me down with its extremely confusing ending and lack luster characters.

Kabaneri_scrn2
Not gonna lie, I thought this was cool as fuck though.

What did you think of Kabaneri? Id love to hear your thoughts? Did you love it, hate it or something in between? Let me know down below!

 

Advertisements

11 thoughts on “Is the hate justified? Lets talk about Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress.

  1. Ah, yes!!! Finally! Someone that enjoyed Kabaneri for what it was even though it had an incredibly bad collapse at the end. Indeed, there were a lot of unanswered questions, but hey! Maybe it’ll be answered in season 2. LOL – I need to finish my own review of this…I only made it up to episode 7 – when Biba arrived, and then finished it by watching the film. Need to go back and finish the series now.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. YAY! I genuinely enjoyed it, but I’m not blind to its flaws either. Thanks for stopping by and commenting, i really appreciate it 😀
      I didn’t know there was a film! Is it like one of those episode recap type movies?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Of course! Anytime! Especially since we have similar tastes and appreciations 😀

        Yes! There were two films actually. The first one is a recap of episodes 1-6 and the Second movie covered 7-12. A local movie theater did a double feature with the films and I went to see it. I’m still currently trying to write my review on it 😦 lol I have too much lined up, but haven’t had a chance to sit down and write yenno? I’m trying to comeback from a slight hiatus too. haha

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Oh thats really cool! Our theatres rarely ever show anything anime related. I think we had a limited run of Your Name but I cant remember anything before that.

        I know what you mean about being busy! Its nice that your are starting to make a come back now though! Always a good time to make new friends ey? 😀

        Liked by 1 person

      3. Agreed! Can never have too many new friends! The ani-blogging community has been great for that so far! 🙂

        Crunchyroll hosted their first “anime move night” and the theater was near work – so I went. But that theater was soooooo weird and sketchy – if they do it there again, I probably will not attend. Gotta try everything at least once right? lol

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I do agee with you. Kabaneri just didn’t measure up to the potential – is it entertaining yes!. And I did find the animation / art drop here and there. I can’t blame the criticism levied at it, this is the 3rd anime where Wit have done a walled off society. Owari no seraph being the second. Biba just sucked, I liked Engrish-san and Takumi.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I’ll be honest my enjoyment of the whole show may have been because Ikoma’s whole transformation at the end was metal AF but I see where you are coming from. I really hope this series gets a sequel so they can try improving on these issues you mentioned but I’m not holding out hope. Glad to know there are more people that liked it for what it is though.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I honestly really enjoyed it! And Ikomas transformation being described as metal af is probably the best thing i could ever have hoped for xD

      Thanks for reading!

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s